Cleaning out some files, I am. Found this bit. Never published it. Must have written it in late 2007, I’m guessing. It’s for the people in #theHoco and those GenXers who find themselves no longer willing to let others dominate the conversation about cities, citizenship, the public and the people. For those not in #theHoco, there was contention around a proposed high-end condo development in my hometown. Here goes:
How it all began
I’ve always considered myself a fairly good citizen. I’m involved, in my own way. I contribute my thinking, energy, solutions and time to civic and community groups. And, for the most part, I’ve just always figured that public leaders, elected and otherwise, had every one’s good interests at heart, and that they’d figure things out and keep things functioning just fine. This perspective worked for me for most of my 35+ years in Columbia.
Then, T-h-e Towers happened.
I read a little here and a little there in the papers. I had a conversation or two or three with those-in-the-know and people whose opinions and thinking I trusted. And then, one day, I learned about the four legal plaintiffs. I read an article in The Flier and something inside of me snapped.
I had crossed a line inside my own life and my own definition of being a citizen. I had grown up in the split of a second. Allow me, please, to try and explain this shift in me.
See, I had watched the fight. I had witnessed a small group of people labeling themselves “the citizens” and “the public.” I had observed the newspapers give unfair and undue credit to this small and vocal group — and its direct opposite — calling such groups “the community.” And while this phenomenon had been OK with me for a couple decades prior, suddenly I was tired of the moralizing. I understand the importance of values and vision, but I couldn’t understand what the fight was about. (And I still don’t.) As I saw it, the tug-of-war had become the news and the discussion.
And in a quiet but galvanizing moment, I realized that I could no longer trust the elder citizens at the helm of all things public. I could no longer trust them to lead the community in a way that serves all of us, rather than just a select few. I could no longer trust the group organizers, the public leaders, the spokespersons and the position-paper writers.
So, I created Hometown Columbia, and I started to blog. I added my perspective, my thinking and my own lens on Living Locally, which included, but certainly hasn’t been focused on T-h-e Tower. I continue to blog, I’ve had a lot more conversations with people-in-the-know and “everyday Joe’s,” I’ve attended public hearings, I’ve read a lot more about this subject, and I’ve become more involved in citizen groups. Now, it’s seven months later. And the issue which triggered my stepping into a public role with Hometown Columbia is not only still at hand; it’s as messy, unresolved, contentious and off-putting as ever. As I see it, the processes we have in place to resolve such issues are out of date and no longer work. The government solutions aren’t working. The press and media are not only not contributing to public dialogue, but are making the tug-of-war worse. And the once-heralded concept of associations and citizen groups is limited.
If you find yourself also feeling disengaged by the moralizing without vision, the attempted compromises that bring no real solution and the small majority of people who represent but one or two perspectives, then perhaps you’d like to check in on Hometown Columbia in the next week or two. You’ll have to bear with me. I’m going to attempt some soul searching. I’m going to share some new thinking, and I’m going to do my best to reframe this situation. And I’m curious to understand how you think about this reframing of the issues, as well.
Happy weekend to you all.